Paul, sounds like you were one of the few with well / correctly tuned engine / ignition to begin with.
Occasionally we see a minimal gain if anything @ WOT RPM
typically we see 100-200 increase @ WOT
and then there are the few that see increase of 300- or more RPM @ WOT
now could we have seen those same gains with the points installed (?) maybe....
however the points contacts will continue to degrade and need to be replaced sooner than later
the electronic ignition kit typically is set it and forget it - plus this bonus replace the cap rotor wires and plugs every few 100 hours instead of every 100 hours
being "electronic" a failure is sure to come sooner or later however in my 15 years or so of carrying them I have yet to have a single failure
if your comfortable with points keep them, they are simple, and with a screwdriver and emery board easy enough to keep functioning or as you put it reliable
I have sold @ least 100 kits per 1 set of points.
When it's tune up time it's @ least worth the consideration.
MSD marine distributor still uses a mechanical advance like the stock conventional distributor, cost about $350 plus wires, and are just a little more involved for the average boat owner to install............
Dan T